The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills are weighing in on Garcelle Beauvais‘ surprise departure.

Hours after the Coming to America actress shocked fans by announcing she’s leaving the show—even before the show’s season 14 reunion airs—her costars shared their very honest opinions about her sudden exit.

“I am disappointed that she is departing like this,” Bozoma Saint John told host Andy Cohen during a March 25 Watch What Happens Live appearance with Erika Jayne. “I wish that she would’ve stuck around to work out another season.”

The season 14 newbie added, “I don’t think that’s a high note.”

For Erika’s part, the “Pretty Mess” singer revealed Garcelle’s exit will make more sense after fans watch the dramatic three-part reunion.

“When we were at the reunion and I knew she was upset,” Erika recounted. “Obviously, we’ve known she’s quit for two weeks. We knew this.”

But when Andy insisted he “did know that she quit” after filming the reunion, Erika called out the Bravo bigwig by replying, “Revisionist history.”