Lindsay Hubbard is confronting some overlap in Carl Radke’s dating life.

In E! News’ exclusive sneak peek at Summer House’s April 9 episode, Carl revealed that he was ready to dive back into the world of romance after his split from Lindsay—whose engagement he’d ended the previous summer—and that he had been on a date the week prior.

But despite Carl saying that his first date with an unnamed woman did not go well, Lindsay accused her ex-fiancé of cheating on her with the same girl before their August 2023 split.

“So that was your first date with her,” Lindsay asked her ex, “because it’s come to my attention that you’ve been talking to her since last summer.”

And when Carl insisted that he had only started messaging the woman in the fall after their breakup, Lindsay requested that he “prove it. Show the receipts.” Conveniently, his phone was charging upstairs.